Not long ago, the District Court of The Hague considered this question and reached a striking conclusion: under certain circumstances, an unsigned will may still be followed, provided it clearly reflects the deceased’s final wishes.
The case: a marriage, a divorce and a missed signature
This case concerned a woman who, shortly after her marriage, discovered that her husband had concealed serious debts. She decided to divorce and instructed a lawyer. At the same time, she approached a notary to exclude her husband from inheriting from her estate. A clear departure from intestate succession. During the meeting with the notary in September 2021, her wishes were recorded in a draft will.
Outstanding invoice
An outstanding invoice was also discussed. A few days later, the draft together with the invoice was sent to her lawyer. The invoice was paid, but the will was never signed. In April 2022, the divorce was granted, but the order had not yet been registered in the civil status registers. Shortly afterwards, the woman died. Legally, she was therefore still married, and under intestate succession her husband was an heir.
The role of reasonableness and fairness
Despite the absence of a signed will, the District Court of The Hague ruled that it would be unacceptable for the husband to inherit. The judge based this on the principle that, if there is complete certainty about the deceased’s final wishes, a draft will may in some circumstances be followed. In this case, statements showed that the woman was convinced that her will had already been arranged. She clearly intended to exclude her husband and acted accordingly. The court concluded that the draft corresponded to her final wishes and that, according to the standards of reasonableness and fairness, it was not defensible to treat the husband as an heir. The result: the court declared that the husband had no entitlement to the estate and treated the draft will as if it had been signed.
What does this mean in practice?
This judgment underlines that the testator’s intention can play a decisive role, even if the will has not been officially signed. In exceptional cases, judges can depart from intestate succession on the basis of reasonableness and fairness, provided there is sufficient evidence that the draft reflects the deceased’s actual wishes.
Nevertheless, the risk remains significant: without a signature, there is no guarantee that a judge will follow the draft. Anyone who wants their estate to be properly arranged would therefore be wise to have the will formally executed by a notary in good time.
Contact
Are you dealing with a similar situation, where a draft will or other expressions of final wishes are central? Then it is advisable to contact one of our inheritance lawyers. They can guide you through the legal settlement. They can also assess whether there is room to depart from intestate succession.