As of 1 January 2020, the so-called cumulatiegrond or i-ground was introduced by the Wet arbeidsmarkt in balans (WAB). It allows the subdistrict court to terminate an employment contract on the basis of a combination of incomplete dismissal grounds, instead of requiring one ground to be fully proven on its own.
The intention and expectation was that it would make dismissal easier for the employer, but against a possible higher price. What does that look like?
The law and the courts set strict requirements for dismissal due to poor performance or a seriously disrupted working relationship. Careful case file building, which takes time, is the key here and is often a stumbling block for a successful dismissal procedure.
With the so-called i-ground or cumulative ground, an employer no longer has to choose only between, for example, a fully documented poor-performance file or a fully broken working relationship. Partial elements of several grounds may be combined. For example, a combination of poor performance and/or a disrupted working relationship and/or seriously culpable conduct by the employee can lead to termination of the employment contract through the court. In practice, the employer must still put forward a sufficiently substantiated case. The i-ground is not meant to replace all case-file building; it only gives the court more room to weigh multiple imperfect grounds together. In practice, judges still apply the i-ground only sparingly in practice.
If the subdistrict court terminates the employment contract on the basis of that cumulative ground, the court can order the employer to pay up to 50% extra transition compensation. That may seem like a lot of money, but keeping an employee on the payroll for a few months longer than desired can already cost more.
Because this cumulative ground can therefore be “more expensive” than dismissal based solely on poor performance or solely on a disrupted relationship, it will usually be put before the court in proceedings as a subsidiary ground for dismissal. In advance negotiations on a settlement agreement, you can already use this combination ground and the slightly higher maximum extra compensation.
For advice on whether your case file is already sufficient for dismissal, the employment law specialists of GMW lawyers are ready to help.
GMW lawyers will be happy to help you with all your employment law issues. Our lawyers assist both employers and employees.
Do you have a question? Please feel free to contact us.
"*" indicates required fields