10 March 2021

Curfew

By Raymond de Mooij

This column was written for Den Haag Central, in which Raymond de Mooij writes monthly about what he experiences in his practice.

On Tuesday, February 16, I was in a telephone call with a client. He wanted to start legal proceedings against the municipality of The Hague. “Think carefully about what you’re getting into,” I told him. “You hardly ever win a procedure against the municipality or the state.”

“I have the idea that judges usually choose the safe way in such cases,” I continued. “Even if you are already successful and a decision is overturned by the judge, then usually a new, amended decision follows. And eventually you draw the short straw.”

The call had barely disconnected before a special report seemed to belie my words. Breaking news! Summary proceedings judge Mr. Hoekstra-van Vliet, in response to a claim by Willem Engel (of action group Virus Truth), had put an end to the criticised curfew, thereby not choosing the safe route. Rutte, Grapperhaus, the Outbreak Management Team and Willem Engel himself were all completely surprised.

Subsequently, a scenario unfolded that you rarely see in day-to-day legal practice. The state asked for a so-called urgent appeal. Such a request is not often honoured, but now it occurred immediately. Moreover, within the framework of that urgent appeal, a request was made to suspend execution of the earlier summary judgment, and it turned out that the judges of the court of The Hague had found a hole in their agenda that same evening to deal with the claim.

Under the leadership of the steadfast chairman, Mr. Tan-de Sonnaville, a legal spectacle unfolded. A screaming Willem Engel, a request to launch a legal challenge, a challenge room that was fortunately ready to reject the request, and to top it all off, the entrance of Professor Jaap van Dissel. He was given an unannounced platform to argue substantive scientific points, while the procedure dealt with a technical-legal topic.

Meanwhile, the talk shows featured the “usual suspects”: criminal lawyers and crime journalists, unhindered by any knowledge of the matter. They looked learned, pulled their frugal mouths and avoided substantive questions.

After the court of The Hague ordered the suspension of the enforceability of the summary judgment, the sequel was somewhat predictable. An emergency law was hastily put together to legitimise the curfew. A week later, the court of The Hague overturned the earlier summary judgment of the court.

And so everything remained as it was. The curfew ticked on quietly and Willem Engel still drew the short straw.

Raymond de Mooij

Raymond de Mooij

Lawyer / partner

‘With the Right Perspective, Every Problem Has a Solution’

Related blogs

Previous slide
Next slide

10 February 2025

The role of housing associations in expanding the mid-market rental segment

Addressing the housing shortage in the Netherlands is a priority. To this end, the National Performance Agreements stipulate that housing associations must construct 50,000 mid-market rental homes by 2030.

Read more

Read more about

20 November 2024

Acquisitive Prescription and Property Boundaries

We regularly handle disputes concerning the acquisition of land through prescription.

Read more

Read more about

28 October 2024

The written requirement when buying a property

When a residential property is sold, this can be done verbally or in writing. If the parties agree on the so-called 'essentials' of the purchase, such as the price and the object, then they are in principle bound to the purchase. However, for a private buyer, there is a written requirement that stipulates that the buyer is only bound to the purchase when it is documented in writing.

Read more

Read more about

4 September 2024

What is the value of common property in a Homeowners Association?

It's not an uncommon situation: a member of the Homeowners Association (HOA) expands their garden or rooftop terrace beyond the boundaries of their private section and later asks the HOA to legalize this change.

Read more

Read more about

12 August 2024

Commonality of a shared wall

Commonality is often a point of discussion between neighbors: is the fence between two gardens common property? If so, can one neighbor then carry out maintenance or even completely replace the fence (partly) at the expense of the other neighbor?

Read more

Read more about
All articles