19 May 2020

Dormant employment and retirement

By Seliz Demirci

Employers do not always dismiss employees who have been ill for more than two years, for example because they expect the person will recover or be able to perform suitable work within a short time.

This situation is referred to as “dormant employment”. In its judgment last November, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands determined that the employer must terminate the employment contract at the request of a long-term sick employee, with payment of a transition allowance. The court recently ruled that this obligation also applies to an employee who has reached retirement age during their illness.

The employee in question had been employed since 2008 and became incapacitated for work in 2015. In 2018, three years after the start of their illness, the employee proposed to the employer to terminate his employment contract by granting the transition allowance.

Compensation scheme

The employee also referred to the compensation scheme that enables employers to receive compensation for the transition allowance paid. However, the employer reacted negatively to this proposal and maintained dormant employment. In 2019, the employee reached retirement age, so their employment ended by operation of law.

Long lasting

The employee then went to court to request a transition payment. The court ruled that the employer should have agreed to the employee’s proposal to terminate dormant employment. The employee was ill for a long time (more than two years) and there were no reintegration options.

Importance

The employer did not have any other legitimate interest in maintaining employment until the employee reached retirement age. The court took into account that employers can claim compensation for the transition allowance paid. Despite the fact that the employment contract had ended by operation of law, the employer had to pay compensation to the employee. In light of the judgment of the Supreme Court, the court decided that it is contrary to good employment practices to maintain dormant employment until the employee retires.

Amount

Because the employment in question had ended due to retirement, the employer did not have to pay a transition allowance, but they had to pay an allowance equal to that amount. In this situation, the employer could no longer claim from the compensation scheme. The opportunity to claim compensation would have existed if the employer had agreed to the employee’s proposal to terminate the employment.

Do not maintain unnecessary dormant employment contracts

The argument that employers are forced to incur costs through their obligation to terminate dormant employment contracts is no longer applicable. Since 1 April 2020, employers can apply for compensation from UWV if they dismiss a long-term sick employee. This means that they will receive the transition compensation retroactively for employment contracts that ended on or after 1 July 2015. However, employers must demonstrate that the employee has been dismissed for long-term illness. In addition, the transition payment due to the employee must be paid out in accordance with the law.

If you as an employer have an interest in continuing the employment, you can maintain the dormant employment. This may be the case with a reintegration option. The fact that the employee has almost reached retirement age is of no importance. If there is no interest in continuing the employment, it is advisable to agree to the sick employee’s proposal to terminate the employment. This also applies when retirement is in sight. This will prevent you from having to pay compensation to the employee afterwards and from being unable to claim the compensation scheme.

Do you have a question?

Please do not hesitate to contact me.

 

This article originally appeared in Rendement.

The Hague Court of Justice, February 4, 2020, ECLI (abbreviated): 146

Seliz Demirci

Seliz Demirci

Lawyer

‘Clear Communication About Problems and Solutions’

Related blogs

Previous slide
Next slide

2 April 2025

Right of consent for works council in a group context

The works council has a legal right of consent when an employer plans to change a remuneration system.

Read more

Read more about

26 March 2025

Copying company information to a private email

In today’s digital workplace, employees generally have easier access to sensitive company information.

Read more

Read more about

18 March 2025

Holiday During Sick Leave: Is Permission Required?

What are the rights and obligations of employees who wish to go on holiday while on sick leave? In this blog, we explain the legal rules, the role of the company doctor, and the possible consequences if a sick employee goes on holiday without permission.

Read more

Read more about

17 March 2025

Obligations under the Collective Dismissal Notification Act

Under the Dutch Collective Dismissal Notification Act (WMCO), you are required to notify the Employment Insurance Agency (UWV) of the dismissal of 20 or more employees within three months. In this blog, we share some practical tips.

Read more

Read more about

5 March 2025

Building a paper trail in Dismissal Cases

Wherever people work together, employment relationships can be disrupted due to various circumstances. If an employer no longer wishes to continue an employment contract for this reason, the court will assess whether there is a valid ground for termination. In such cases, the dismissal file plays a crucial role.

Read more

Read more about
All articles